Plastics in fashion: a review of plastic materials in modern and contemporary costume collections and their conservation

Alazne Porcel Ziarsolo

doi:10.14568/cp27897

Authors

Alazne Porcel Ziarsolo Department of Painting, Faculty of Fine Arts, University of the Basque Country (UPV/EHU), Spain https://orcid.org/0000-0002-6275-2211

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.14568/cp27897

Keywords:

Costume, Contemporary fashion collections, Plastics, Synthetic materials, Conservation

Abstract

The conservation of plastics has become a real concern in fashion collections. The researches carried in the last years in institutions dedicated to preserve modern and contemporary clothing, show the existence of a surprising number of polymeric materials, natural based or chemically synthetized, as well as several emerging conservation problems related to them. Literature and publicity from the 19th and 20th centuries evidences that their introduction to fashion was possible thanks to scientific and technical discoveries focused in obtaining lower-budget alternatives to costly materials historically used in jewelry and dressmaking. These discoveries lead to the creation of a new range of materials that revolutionized fashion, from the earliest moldable materials to the first artificial plastics produced by chemical modification and finally, synthetic plastics. The present work aims to review the characteristics, applications and conservation of plastic materials within contemporary costume collections, which nowadays, represent a big challenge for the field.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

Arbeteta Mira, L. (coord.), La joyería española en los museos estatales de Felipe II a Alfonso XII, editorial Nerea, Madrid (1988).

Espinoza, F.; Araya, C., ‘Materiales modernos en la colección textil del Museo Histórico Nacional de Chile’, Revista Conserva 10 (2006) 55-70.

Steele, V., The corset: a cultural History, Yale University Press, New Haven & London (2001).

Mossman, S., Early plastics. Perspectives 1850-1950, Leicester University Press, London (1997).

Quye, A.; Williamson, C., Plastics, collecting and conserving, NMS Publishing Limited, Edinburgh (1999).

Horta Zubiaga, A.; Sánchez Renamayor, C.; Pérez Dorado, A.; Martínez de Olcoz, I. F. de P., Los plásticos más usados, Universidad Nacional de Educación a Distancia, UNED, Madrid (2000).

Van Oosten, T., ‘The degradation of early synthetic materials incorporated in the accessories of a textile collection: cellulose nitrate, cellulose acetate, galalith, bakelite’, in International perspectives on textile conservation, eds. Á. Tímar-Balázsy and D. Eastop, ICOM-CC, Amsterdam (1998) 4-7.

Waentig, F., Plastics in art-A study from the conservation point of view, Michael Imhof Verlag, Petesberg (2008).

Morgan, J., Conservation of plastics, an introduction to their history, manufacture, deterioration, identification and care, Plastics Historical Society London, London (1991).

García Fernández-Villa, S.; San Andrés Moya, M., ‘El plástico como bien de interés cultural (I). Aproximación a la historia y composición de los plásticos de moldeo naturales y artificiales’, PH Boletín 40/41 (2002) 87-102, https://doi.org/10.33349/2002.40.1415.

García Fernández-Villa, S., Los plásticos en el arte y el diseño hasta 1945, PhD dissertation, Department of Painting, Universidad Complutense de Madrid, Madrid (2010), http://eprints.ucm.es/11670/ (accessed 2022-08-08).

Madden, O., ‘Balancing ingenuity and responsibility in the age of plastic’, in The Age of Plastic: Ingenuity and Responsibility Proceedings of the 2012 MCI Symposium, eds. O. Madden, A. E. Charola, K. C. Cobb, P. T. dePriest and R. J. Koestler, Smithsonian contributions to museum conservation 7 (2017) 1-17, https://bit.ly/3idahqd (accessed 2022-08-08).

França de Sá, S.; Marques da Cruz, S.; Callapez, M. E.; Carvalho, V., ‘Plastics that made history – the contribution of conservation science for the history of the Portuguese plastics industry’, Conservar Património 35 (2020) 85-100, https://doi.org/10.14568/cp2019017.

Tonkin, L., ‘Visionary design practices: preserving plastics and designers’ intent in collections of modern and contemporary fashion’, Journal of the Institute of Conservation 40(2) (2017) 152-167, https://doi.org/10.1080/19455224.2017.1321561.

Regan, J., ‘Women in black: fashioning mourning in the 19th century’, [Conference], Metropolitan Museum of New York, New York (2014).

Steele, S., ‘Back to black’, Gems & Jewellery 25(3) (2016) 16-20, https://bit.ly/38FvoP5 (accessed 2022-08-08).

Katz, S., Classic plastics: from bakelite to high-tech, with a collector's guide, Thames & Hudson, London (1984).

Lambert, S., ‘Making the Most of Your Plastics’, in The Collections Trust (2008), https://bit.ly/3PlXZLi (accessed 2022-08-08).

Tiley-Nel, S.; Antonites, A. R., Archaeological worked bone and ivory - a guide to best practice in preservation, research and curation, University of Pretoria, Pretoria (2015).

‘Whalebone and its substitutes’, in La Couturier Parisienne (2013), http://www.marquise.de/en/themes/howto/fischbein.shtml (accessed 2022-08-08).

Tisdall, L. P., ‘Corset mounting for undressed: the bones of the matter’, V & A Blog (2017), https://bit.ly/3FXFEjq (accessed 2022-08-08).

‘The celluloid corset clasps. Side and dress steels, warranted not to rust’, Chinese immigration in the late 19th century, Doener and Gunther's, New York (c. 1885), https://digital.librarycompany.org/islandora/object/digitool%3A106881 (accessed 2022-08-08).

Krieg, T.; Mazzon, C.; Gómez-Sánchez, E., ‘Material analysis and a visual guide of degradation phenomena in historical synthetic polymers as tools to follow ageing processes in industrial heritage collections’, Polymers 14(1) (2022) 121, https://doi.org/10.3390/polym14010121.

Hainschwang, T.; Leggio, L., ‘The characterization of tortoise shell and its imitations’, Gems & Gemology 42(1) (2006) 36–52, https://bit.ly/3o9TbLM (accessed 2021-11-08).

‘On horn and tortoiseshell’, Transactions of the Society, Instituted at London, for the Encouragement of Arts, Manufactures, and Commerce 52(2) (1838) 334-349, http://www.jstor.org/stable/41326836 (accessed 2022-08-08).

Meikle, J. L., American plastic; a cultural history, Rutger University Press, New Brunswick (1997).

Florian, M., Protein facts, fibrous proteins in cultural and natural history artifacts, Archetype Publications, London (2007).

‘The care and handling of ivory’, in Smithsonian Museum Conservation Institute, https://s.si.edu/3EtFXRJ (accessed 2022-08-08).

Fenn, J., ‘The care of horn and tortoise shell’, Ontario Museum Quarterly 12(1) (1983) 26-28.

‘Antique tortoiseshell, ivory, bone & mother of pearl: cleaning and storing’, in Conservation Housekeeping (2022), https://bit.ly/3FTV6QX (accessed 2022-05-28).

Karen, V., ‘Conservation of a tortoiseshell book cover’, Victoria & Albert Museum Conservation Journal 50 (2005) 48-50, https://bit.ly/314ki5a (accessed 2022-08-08).

Trusheim, L., ‘Balancing ethics and restoration in the conservation treatment of an 18th century sewing box with tortoiseshell veneer’, in AIC Objects Specialty Group Postprints, eds. S. Balachandran, C. Del Re and C. Riccardelli, The American Institute for Conservation of Historic & Artistic Works, Washington DC (2011) 127-147, https://bit.ly/3swopC7 (accessed 2022-08-08).

Morris, R.; Keneghan, B., ‘Cold war fashion. Two case studied from an exhibition at the Victoria & Albert Museum Materials’, in The Conservation of modern material in applied arts and design, ed. T. Bechthold, Die Neue Sammlung, The International Design Museum Munich, Munich (2009) 110-117, https://bit.ly/3UdPowW (accessed 2022-10-28).

Gim, J.; Schnitzer, N.; Otter, L. M.; Cui, Y.; Motreuil, S.; Marin, F.; Wolf, S. E.; Jacob, D. E.; Misra, A.; Hovden, R., ‘Nanoscale deformation mechanics reveal resilience in nacre of Pinna nobilis shell’, Nature Communications 10 (2019) 4822, https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-019-12743-z.

Currey, J. D., ‘Mechanical properties of mother of pearl in tension’, Proceedings of the Royal Society of London B 196(1125) (1977) 443-463, https://doi.org/10.1098/rspb.1977.0050.

‘Imitation mother of pearl buttons’, in MODIP-Museum of Design in Plastics, https://www.modip.ac.uk/artefact/aibdc-008323 (accessed 2022-10-28).

‘Conservation and care of collections: a practical guide to the conservation and care of collections’, in Western Australian Museum, eds. I. Godfrey and D. Gilroy (1st ed., 1998) (2017), https://manual.museum.wa.gov.au/book/export/html/1 (accessed 2022-10-28).

Robertson, P., The shell book of firsts, Ebury Press, London (1974).

‘Thomas Hornby Birley’, in Eccles Old Road, https://bit.ly/2N1hf6l (accessed 2022-08-08).

Rexford, N, Women’s shoes in America, 1795-1930, Kent State University Press, Kent (2000).

Connors, S. A.; Chemical and physical characterization of the degradation of vulcanized natural rubber in the museum environment, Master Dissertation, Department of Conservation, Queens University, Kingston Ontario, (1998), https://bit.ly/3M4i1vn (accessed 2022-10-08).

Brydson, J. A., Plastics materials, 7th ed., Butterworth and Heinemann, United Kingdom (2002).

Katz, S., Early plastics, Bloomsbury Publishing PLC, London (1994).

Thickett, D.; Cruickshank, P.; Ward, C., ‘The conservation of amber’, Studies in Conservation 40(4) (1995) 217-226, https://doi.org/10.1179/sic.1995.40.4.217.

Leshner, L., Collecting art plastic jewelry, KP Books, USA (2005).

Mossman, S., ‘The technology of early plastics’, in The plastics age: from modernity to post-Modernity, ed. P. Sparke, Victoria and Albert Museum, London (1990) 17-24.

Paulocik, C.; Williams, R. C., ‘The chemical composition and conservation of late 19th and early 20th century sequins’, Journal of the Canadian Association for Conservation 35 (2010) 46-61, Vol35_doc5.pdf (cac-accr.ca) (accessed 2022-08-08).

Loewen, J., Millinery, Macmillan, New York (1925).

Plastics and design, ed. Hufnagl, F., Exhibition Catalogue, Neue Sammlung (Design Museum), Munich, Arnoldsche Verlagsanstalt, Stuttgart (1997).

Toller, J., Papier-mâché in Great Britain and America, G. Bell & Sons, Ltd, London, (1962).

‘Prestoff’, in Leather encyclopedia, https://prorestorers.co.uk/knowledgebase/presstoff/ (accessed 2022-10-28).

Carrlee, E., ‘Shipwreck doll’, in Ellen Carrlee conservation blog (2013), https://ellencarrlee.wordpress.com/tag/gutta-percha/ (accessed 2022-08-08).

Fulcher, K., ‘An investigation of the use of cellulose-based materials to gap-fill wooden objects’, Studies in Conservation 62(4) (2017) 210-222, https://doi.org/10.1080/00393630.2015.1109294.

Levitt, S., ‘Manchester Mackintoshes: A history of the rubberized garment trade in Manchester’, Textile History 17(1) (1986) 51-69, https://doi.org/10.1179/004049686793700980.

Charpy, M., ‘Craze and shame: rubber clothing during the nineteenth century in Paris, London, and New York city’, Fashion Theory 16(4) (2012) 433-460, https://doi.org/10.2752/175174112X13427906403769.

Shephard, A. J., ‘L. Candee & Co. and the U.S. rubber shoe industry’, Clothing and Textiles Research Journal 38(4) (2020) 255-269, https://doi.org/10.1177/0887302X20918018.

Amstrong, S., ‘The trench coat's forgotten WW1 roots’, in BBC News (2014), https://bbc.in/3qifHTG (accessed 2022-08-08).

Porcel Ziarsolo, A.; Artetxe Sánchez, E., ‘Una introducción a los textiles artificiales en las colecciones de indumentaria del siglo XX y su conservación’, Ge-conservación 9 (2016) 31-44, https://doi.org/10.37558/gec.v9i0.276.

Seymour, R. B.; Carraher, C. E., Introducción a la química de los polímeros, Editorial Reverté S.A., Barcelona (2002).

Mossman, S., ‘Plastics in the science museum, London: a curator’s view’, in Saving the twentieth century: the conservation of Modern materials, ed. D.W. Grattan, Canadian Conservation Institute, Ottawa (1993) 25-35.

Morgan, J., ‘A survey of plastics in historical collections’, in Plastics historical society and the conservation unit of the museums & galleries commission (1994), https://bit.ly/33xcy9C (accessed 2022-08-08).

Williamson, C., ‘Landmarks in the history of plastics’, in Plastics: collecting and conserving, eds. A. Quye and C. Williamson, NMS Publishing Limited, (1999) 2-22.

‘Plastic identification tool – plastics, casein formaldehyde (CF)’, in Cultural Heritage Agency of the Netherlands (RCE), https://plastic-en.tool.cultureelerfgoed.nl/plastics/detail/CF (accessed 2022-08-08).

‘Casein’, in CAMEO-Materials Database, http://cameo.mfa.org/wiki/Casein_plastic (accessed 2022-08-08).

Kaner, J.; Ioras, F.; Ratnasingam, J., ‘Performance and stability of historic casein formaldehyde’, e-plastory 2 (2017) 1-18, https://bit.ly/35E9vNS (accessed 2022-08-08).

Friedel, R., ‘The first plastic’, in The plastics age: from modernity to post-modernity, ed. P. Sparke, Victoria and Albert Museum, London (1990) 25-31.

Haldane, E. A., ‘Surreal semi-synthetics’, Victoria & Albert Museum Conservation Journal 55 (2007) 14-18, https://bit.ly/3mVuToD (accessed 2022-08-08).

‘Xylonite collar’, in MODIP-Museum of Design in Plastics, https://bit.ly/3qi8L94 (accessed 2022-08-08).

Meikle, J. L., ‘Presenting a new material: from imitation to innovation with fabrikoid’, The Journal of the Decorative Arts Society 1850 - the Present 19 (1995) 8-15, www.jstor.org/stable/41805870 (accessed 2022-08-08).

Prichard, S.; Smith, S., ‘Taking a risk: collecting for the future’, in Plastics, looking the future and learning from the past, ed. B. Keneghan and L. Egan, Archetype Publications and Victoria & Albert Museum, London (2008) 132-137.

Everts, S., ‘Preserving plastic art’, Chemical & Engineering News 89(29) (2011) 29-31, https://bit.ly/3bDQ0sQ (accessed 2022-08-08).

Shashoua, Y., ‘A safe place. Storage strategies for plastics’, The GCI Newsletter 29(1) (2014) 13-15, https://bit.ly/3e7edaX (accessed 2022-08-08).

Lunau, M., ‘Plastic wrapping: do’s and don’ts in storage’, in Western Museums Association (2015), https://westmuse.org/articles/plastic-wrapping (accessed 2022-08-08).

Berkson, J., Carry me! 1950's Lucite handbags: an American fashion, ACC Editions, Suffolk (2009).

Société des usines chimiques Rhône-Poulenc, Le Rhodoïd et les matières plastiques à base d'acétate de cellulose: Rhodialite, Rhodialine, Rhodax, Impr. R. Duperche, Paris (1930), http://cnum.cnam.fr/redir?M12206 (accessed 2022-08-08).

Rogerson, C., Preserving jewellery created from plastics and rubber: application of materials and interpretation of objects, PhD dissertation, School of Humanities, The Royal College of Art of London, London (2009).

‘Preservation of plastics. Cellulose esters (cellulose nitrate and cellulose acetate)’, in The Getty Conservation Institute (2017), https://bit.ly/3EnWSW5 (accessed 2022-08-08).

Elsässer, C.; Micheluz, A.; Pamplona, M.; Kavda, S.; Montag, P., ‘Selection of thermal, spectroscopic, spectrometric, and chromatographic methods for characterizing historical celluloid’, Journal of Applied Polymer Science 138(21) (2021) 50477, https://doi.org/10.1002/app.50477.

Selwitz, C., Cellulose nitrate in conservation, The Getty Conservation Institute, Los Angeles (1988).

Sutherland, K.; Schwarzinger, C.; Price, B. A, ‘The application of pyrolysis gas chromatography mass spectrometry for the identification of degraded early plastics in a sculpture by Naum Gabo’, Journal of Analytical and Applied Pyrolysis 94 (2012) 202-208, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jaap.2011.12.016.

Mazurek, J.; Laganà, A.; Dion, V.; Etyemez, S.; Carta, C.; Schilling, M. R., ‘Investigation of cellulose nitrate and cellulose acetate plastics in museum collections using ion chromatography and size exclusion chromatography’, Journal of Cultural Heritage 35 (2019) 263–270, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.culher.2018.05.011.

Tolkien, T.; Wilkinson, H., Collector's guide to costume jewelry: Key Styles and how to recognize them, Firefly Books Ltd, Willowdale, ON, (1997).

Baekeland, L. H., ‘The synthesis, constitution and uses of bakelite’, The Journal of Industrial and Engineering Chemistry 1(3) (1909) 149-161.

Shashoua, Y., Conservation of plastics. Materials science, degradation and preservation, Butterworth-Heinemann, Oxford (2008).

Smith, S. S., ‘Time crumbles plastic artifacts: museums fighting to conserve history’, in Plastic News (1997), https://bit.ly/3qwNOJA (accessed 2022-08-08).

Kaufman, M., The first century of plastics: celluloid and its sequel, The Plastics and Rubber Institute, London (1963).

Rowling, R., ‘Melamine buttons’, in PowerHouse Collection (2008), https://collection.maas.museum/object/240662 (accessed 2022-10-25).

‘History- the plexiglass name’, in PLEXIGLAS, History - PLEXIGLAS® (accessed 2022-10-25).

Bennet, B., ‘Perspex jewellery’, Plastiquarian 15 (winter) (1995-1996), 26.

Lupano, M.; Vaccari, A. (eds.), Fashion at the time of fascism: Italian modernist lifestyle, 1922-1943, Damiani, Bologna (2009).

‘Preservation of plastics. Repair studies’, in The Getty Conservation Institute (2017), https://bit.ly/3psaviv (accessed 2022-08-08).

Laganà, A.; David, M.; Doutre, M.; Groot, S. de; van Keulen, H.; Madden, O.; Schilling, M.; van Bommel, M., ‘Reproducing reality. Recreating bonding defects observed in transparent poly(methyl methacrylate) museum objects and assessing defect formation’, Journal of Cultural Heritage 48 (2021) 254–268, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.culher.2020.11.002.

Kavda, S.; Golfomitsou, S.; Richardson, E., ‘Effects of selected solvents on PMMA after prolonged exposure: unilateral NMR and ATR-FTIR investigations’, Heritage Science 11 (2023) 63, https://doi.org/10.1186/s40494-023-00881-z.

Yarsley, V. W.; Couzenz, E. G., ‘Plastics and the future’, in The plastics age: from modernity to post-modernity, ed. P. Sparke, Victoria and Albert Museum, London (1990) 55-60.

Penfold, A., Reports on plastics investigation, 1945 in the United States of America, Canada and the United Kingdom, Sydney Technological Museum Memorandum, Sydney, (1945).

Tonkin, L., ‘Fashioning the future of poly (vinyl chloride). A preliminary investigation into the effects of cool temperatures on PVC present in modern and contemporary fashion in museum collections’, in Future Talks 017: The silver edition. Visions. Innovations in technology and conservation of the modern, The Design Museum, Munich (2019) 68-75.

Lavédrine, B; Fournier, A.; Martin, G., Preservation of plastic artefacts in museum collections, Éditions du Comité des travaux historiques et scientifiques, Paris (2012).

Shashoua, Y., Inhibiting the deterioration of plasticized poly (vinyl chloride): a museum perspective, PhD dissertation, Department of Conservation, Danish Polymer Centre & The Technical University of Denmark, Lyngby (2001), https://bit.ly/39xxa3K (accessed 2022-08-08).

Jennifer, N., ‘How to rescue fashion before it self-destructs’, Conservation Lab, VICE (2017), https://bit.ly/3sq6ydO (accessed 2022-08-08).

The Textile Institute, Identification of textile materials, 7th ed., The Textile Institute, Manchester (1st ed. 1951) (1985).

Blank, S., ‘An introduction to plastics and rubbers in collections’, Studies in Conservation 35 (1990) 53-63, http://dx.doi.org/10.1179/sic.1990.35.2.53.

Van Oosten, T., PUR facts. Conservation of polyurethane foam in art and design, Amsterdam University Press, Amsterdam (2011).

Kerr, N.; Batcheller, J., ‘Degradation of polyurethanes in 20th century museum textiles’, in Saving the twentieth century: the conservation of modern materials, ed. D.W. Grattan, Canadian Conservation Institute, Ottawa (1993) 189-206.

Kanigel, R., Faux real: genuine leather and 200 years of inspired fakes, Joseph Henry Press, Washington DC (2007).

Lovett, D.; Eastop, D., ‘The degradation of polyester polyurethane: preliminary study of 1960s foam-laminated dresses’, in Modern art, new museums, ed. A. Roy and P. Smith, International Institute for Conservation of Historic and Artistic Works, London (2004) 100-104.

O’ Hara Callan, G., Diccionario de la moda y los diseñadores, Ediciones Destino, Barcelona (1999).

Spivack, E., ‘A history of sequins from King Tut to the King of Pop’, in Smithsonianmag (2012), https://bit.ly/37GHgQp (accessed 2022-08-08).

Ekström, G., ‘Ett glaskart alternativ-Polykarbonat’, Plastforum Scandanavia 6 (1985) 94.

‘Neoprene (Polychloroprene)’, in PHS Plastics Historical Society, http://plastiquarian.com/?page_id=14244 (accessed 2022-10-28).

Shephard, A. J., ‘Waterproof dress: patents as evidence of design and function from 1880 through 1895’, Clothing and Textiles Research Journal 30 (2012) 183-199, https://doi.org/10.1177/0887302X12452910.

Stoughton Harris, C., ‘Treatment of 20th-century rubberized multimedia costume: conservation of a Mary Quant raincoat (ca. 1967)’, in Saving the twentieth century: the conservation of modern materials, ed. D.W. Grattan, Canadian Conservation Institute, Ottawa (1993) 213-222.

Keneghan, B., ‘Plastics? Not in my collection’, Conservation Journal 21 (1996) 4-6, https://bit.ly/3nTxWgy (accessed 2022-08-08).

Keneghan, B., ‘A survey of synthetic plastic and rubber objects in the collections of the Victoria and Albert Museum’, Museum management curatorship 19(3) (2001) 19-321, https://doi.org/10.1080/09647770101001903.

Cosgrove, B., ‘Modern materials in fashion collections: a conservation issue for the National Gallery of Victoria’, in Textile Symposium, Australian Institute for the Conservation of Cultural Materials, Moonah (2006) 55-61, https://bit.ly/2NvVyeY (accessed 2022-08-08).

França de Sá, S.; Verkens, K.; Rizzo, A.; Petersen, G.; Scaturro, S.; Correia, I.; Carita, M., ‘Synthetic coatings in fashion collections: identification and preservation issues’, in Handbook of Museum Textiles, Vol. 2, eds. S. Jose, S. Thomas, P. Pandit and R. Pandey, John Wiley & Sons, New Jersey(2022) 319-344.

Fernández-Villa, S. G.; San Andrés, M.; De la Roja, J. M., ‘Conservar el diseño industrial: problemas prácticos en la identificación de piezas de plástico’, in Conservación de Arte Contemporáneo 11ª Jornada, Museo Nacional Centro de Arte Reina Sofía, Madrid (2010) 331-358, https://bit.ly/38uBO25 (accessed 2022-08-08).

‘Plastics identification toll – About project Plastics’, in Cultural Heritage Agency of the Netherlands (2019), https://bit.ly/3stGEIy (accessed 2022-08-08).

Fenn, J.; Williams, R.S., ‘Caring for plastics and rubbers’, in Preventive conservation guidelines for collections - Canadian Conservation Institute, bit.ly/42cmgdP (accessed 2023-05-06).

‘Innovative packaging solutions for storage and conservation of 20th century cultural heritage of artefacts based on cellulose derivative’, in NEMOSINE project, https://nemosineproject.eu (accessed 2023-05-06).

Shashoua, Y.; Schilling, M.; Mazurek, J., ‘The effectiveness of conservation adsorbents at inhibiting degradation of cellulose acetate’, in 17th Triennial Conference ICOM-CC - Modern Materials and Contemporary Art, International Council of Museums, Paris (2014), 1010.