Displaying a taxidermy rhinoceros in a museum: the Lisbon conservation approach
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.14568/cp2018043Keywords:
Horn, Replica, Replacement, Ethics, Preventive restorationAbstract
The present problems around the public display of a full taxidermy mounted rhinoceros in Lisbon and the motifs for the replacement of its original horns are presented in this paper. The twentieth century specimen concerned belongs to the National Museum of Natural History and Science of the University of Lisbon (MUHNA C). The several warnings of rhino horn thefts occurring in museums across Europe in the last two decades and the frequency of requests for loans of this specimen for exhibitions, raised an internal debate at the MUHNA C. In this paper, firstly, we present a short overview of the problems in terms of the international context and the vulnerability of these specimens at museums, followed by a brief overview of the history of the Lisbon specimen. Finally, we detail and discuss our conservation, methodology and ethical approach to the removal and replacement of the specimen’s original horns with replicas, based on Norfolk Museums Service’s (UK) protocol and experience.
Received: 2018-10-7
Revised: 2019-3-4
Accepted: 2019-4-8
Online: 2019-6-18
Publication: 2020-3-13
Downloads
References
[1] Viscardi, P., `The horns of a dilemma: the impact of the illicit trade in rhino horn’, NatSCA News 22 (2012) 8-13, http://www.natsca.org/article/107.
[2] Pleasance, C., `Dozens of rhinos died so someone could buy these `trophies': Record £12million haul of rhinoceros horn is seized in Malaysian airport destined for Vietnamese `health trade'' (2018-08-20), in Mail Online, https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-6079177/50-rhino-horns-worth-12m-seized-Malaysia-airport-bound-Vietnam.html (accessed 2018-9-1).
[3] Lourenço, M. C.; Eiró, A., `O Museu de Ciência’, in Património da Universidade de Lisboa: Ciência e Arte, ed. M. C. Lourenço & M. J. Neto, Tinta-da-china / Universidade de Lisboa, Lisboa (2011) 35-54.
[4] Póvoas, L.; Lopes, C. I; Melo, I; Correia, A. I.; Alves, M. J.; Cardoso, H.; Galopim, A. M. G.,`O Museu Nacional de História Natural’, in Património da Universidade de Lisboa: Ciência e Arte, ed. M. C. Lourenço & M. J. Neto, Tinta-da-china / Universidade de Lisboa, Lisboa (2011) 17-34.
[5] Felismino, D., Saberes, Natureza e Poder. Colecções Científicas da Antiga Casa Real Portuguesa, Caleidoscópio, Casal de Cambra (2014).
[6] `Decreto-Lei n.ë 141/2015 de 31 de julho’, Diário da República ± 1.ã série (148) (2015-7-31), 5185-5188.
[7] Lobato, A., Da Comissão de Cartographia ao Instituto de Investigação Científica Tropical (1983-1983). Memória Histórica, Instituto de Investigação Científica Tropical, Lisboa (1983).
[8] Grove, L; Thomas, S., `ªThe rhino horn on display has been replaced by a replicaº: museum security in Finland and England’, Journal of Conservation and Museum Studies 14(1), 1-11, https://doi.org/10.5334/jcms.124.
[9] Gao, Y.; Stoner, K. J.; Lee, A. T. L.; Clark, S. G., `Rhino horn trade in China: an analysis of the art and antiques market’, Biological Conservation 201 (2016) 343-347, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.biocon.2016.08.001.
[10] Nowell, K., `Species trade and conservation. Rhinoceroses: Assessment of rhino horn as a traditional medicine’, report for the CITES Secretariat SC62 Doc. 47.2 Annex (Rev.2) (2012), http://www.rhinoresourcecenter.com/index.php?s=1&act=pdfviewer&id=1389957235&folder=138 (accessed 2019-6-11).
[11] `Europol and Ireland identify organised crime group active in illegal trading of rhino horn ± Press release' (2011-7-7), Europol, https://www.europol.europa.eu/newsroom/news/europol-and-ireland-identify-organised-crime-group-active-in-illegal-trading-of-rhino-horn (accessed 2018-9-1).
[12] Hewitt, D., `How the high price of rhino horn fuels European museum thefts' (2012-7-1), The Star, https://www.thestar.com/news/world/2012/07/01/how_the_high_price_of_rhino_horn_fuels_european_museum_thefts.html (accessed 2018-9-1).
[13] `Rhinoceros horn stockpiles ± a serious threat to rhinos' (2011-08-31), Humane Society International, http://www.hsi.org/assets/pdfs/rhino_horn_stockpiles_report.pdf (accessed 2018-6-1).
[14] `Fact sheet: rhino horn museum heists' (2011-7-20), in Culture Heritage Law, Lawyers' Committee for Cultural Heritage Preservation, https://www.culturalheritagelaw.org/rhinofactsheet (accessed 2018-9-1).
[15] Woolfoot, A., `Cirencester auctioneer Chris Surfleet escapes jail sentence after admitting rhino horn theft' (2009-12-11), in Wilts and Gloucestershire Standard.
[16] Landes, D., `Swedish museum hit by rhino horn heist' (2011-7-27), The Local, https://www.thelocal.se/20110727/35186 (accessed 2018-9-1).
[17] Atkinson, R., `Twenty thefts of rhino horn in six months' (2011-8-10), in Museums Association News, Museums Association, https://www.museumsassociation.org/museums-journal/news/10082011-rhino-horm (accessed 2016-9-1).
[18] Atkinson, R., `Staff foil smash-and-grab rhino horn raid' (2012-2-22), in Museums Association News, Museums Association, https://www.museumsassociation.org/museums-journal/news/22012012-staff-foil-smash-and-grab-rhino-horn-theft (accessed 2016-9-1).
[19] Pinto, N. T., `Traficantes de chifres de rinoceronte assaltam em Portugal' (2014-12-14), in Sábado, http://www.sabado.pt/portugal/seguranca/detalhe/os-traficantes-de-chifres-de-rinoceronte (accessed 2016-9-1).
[20] Virtuani, P., `Corni di rinoceronte a rischio anche in Italia: rubati dai musei' (2015-9-22), in Corriere della Sera, https://www.corriere.it/scienze/15_settembre_22/corni-rinoceronte-rubati-musei-2458db8a-6116-11e5-9c25-5a9b04a29dee.shtml?refresh_ce-cp (Access in 2019-02).
[21] Ring, W., `Rhino horn stolen from University of Vermont; reward offered' (2017-5-03), in APnews, https://apnews.com/7aefbd84420e4ab09540e21828de2374/Rhino-horn-stolen-from-University-of-Vermont;-reward-offered (accessed 2018-9-1).
[22] Pleasance, C., `Dozens of rhinos died so someone could buy these `trophies': Record £12 million haul of rhinoceros horn is seized in Malaysian airport destined for Vietnamese ªhealth tradeº' (2018-8-20), in Mail Online, https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-6079177/ (accessed 2018-9-1).
[23] Dias, M., `Suspeito de furto de chifres de rinoceronte foi detido pela PJ' (2013-03-18), in Público, https://www.publico.pt/1588236 (accessed 2016-9-1).
[24] Amarro, J. B., `Tráfico de cornos de rinoceronte, um negócio de milhões travado em Lisboa' (2011-9-6), in Público, https://www.publico.pt/22886715 (accessed 2016-9-1).
[25] `Rhino Horn’, in NatSCA, Natural Sciences Collections Association, https://www.natsca.org/rhino-horn-guidance-museums (accessed 2018-9-1).
[26] Pereira, R. D., `História do J. M. A. U. 1906-1993’, unpublished, IICT, Universidade de Lisboa, Lisboa, CDI-IICT R5676 (1993).
[27] `[Of.ë 37 de 1957-01-11] Copiador de Correspondência para o ano de 1957’, manuscript, JMAU, Universidade de Lisboa, Lisboa, uncatalogued, PT/MUL/IICT/JBT/07 (1957).
[28] `Ajustamento e restauro de embalsamento de dois rinocerontes oferecidos ao futuro Museu do Ultramar pelo Sr. J.J. Fenykövi [28-1-1958]`, manuscript, Arquivo Histórico Ultramarino, Lisboa, uncatalogued, AHU/MU/AGU/Repartição de Serviços de Informação e Relações Exteriores/Informações Expedidas (1958).
[29] `Jardim e Museu Agrícola do Ultramar’, in Da Comissão de Cartographia (1883) ao Instituto de Investigação Científica Tropical (1983). 100 anos, IICT, Lisboa (1983) 181-193.
[30] Guia do Museu Agrícola do Ultramar, Ministério do Ultramar, Lisboa (1961).
[31] Pereira, J. D., `O Museu Agrícola Tropical’, unpublished, IICT, Universidade de Lisboa, Lisboa, CDI-IICT R6832 (1984).
[32] Costa, M.; Abreu, R.; Moura, L.; Moriés, B.; Gonçalves, C.; Casanova, C., `Criação de reservas técnicas para as coleções científicas do IICT ± work in progress’, in IX Jornadas de Arte e Ciência da UCP| V Jornadas da ARP. Homenagem a Luís Elias Casanovas. A Prática da Conservação Preventiva., ed. E. Vieira, Universidade Católica Editora, Porto (2015) 195-205.
[33] Casanova, C., `The heritage of the Tropical Research Institute, Lisbon: A case-study and a strategy’, in Spaces and Collections in the History of Science. The Laboratorio Chimico Overture, ed. M. C. Lourenço & A. Carneiro, Museum of Science of the University of Lisbon, Lisboa (2009) 245-257.
[34] Ance. A., `Killer of biggest animal ever slain by man claims camera shooting is most dangerous’, Desert Sun 32(189) (1959) 10B, https://cdnc.ucr.edu/?a=d&d=DS19590415.2.128.
[35] Fenykövi, J., Angola no Visor da Máquina Fotográfica e da Carabina, Edições Diana, Lisboa (1958).
[36] `The History of Rowland Ward Ltd.’, Rowland Ward Ltd., https://rowlandward.com/about/ (accessed 2018-9-1).
[37] `Exposição «Cidades da CPLP ± Gravuras do Arquivo Histórico Ultramarino» inaugurada no Palácio da Calheta' (2006-12-4), in IICT Saber Tropical Knowledge, IICT, http://www2.iict.pt/?idc=231&idi=12633 (accessed 2018-9-1).
[38] Martins, A. C.; Albino, T. (ed.), Viagens e Missões Científicas nos Trópicos: 1883-2010, Instituto de Investigação Científica Tropical, Lisboa (2010).
[39] `Exposição ªCulturas e Plantasº' (2014-9-30), in IICT Saber Tropical Knowledge, IICT, http://www2.iict.pt/?idc=231&idi=24187 (accessed 2018-9-1).
[40] Almeida, I. C; Rodrigo, A. L., O Rinoceronte: Pegadas na Torre, exposição Torre de Belém, Jan. 92 ± Jun. 92, Torre de Belém, Lisboa (1992).
[41] Kilchmann, P., `O Rinoceronte de Dürer (Dürer`s Rhinoceronte) from us.’, in Peter Kilchmann, http://www.peterkilchmann.com/artists/overview/++/name/javier-t%25C3%25A9llez/id/24/media/_dsc7602.jpg/ (Access at 2012-12).
[42] Marmeleira, J., `Fora e dentro de campo' (2010-06-02), in Público, https://www.publico.pt/1656333 (accessed 2012-12-1).
[43] Leitão, H. (ed.); 360ë Ciência Descoberta, Fundação Calouste Gulbenkian, Lisboa (2013).
[44] Gschwend, A. J.; Lowe K. J. P. (ed.), A Cidade Global. Lisboa no Renascimento / The Global City. Lisbon in the Renaissance, Museu Nacional de Arte Antiga ± Instituto Nacional Casa da Moeda, Lisboa (2017).
[45] Pinto, M., `Uma ªCidade Globalº para descobrir no Museu Soares dos Reis' (2017-5-29), in JPN, Universidade do Porto, https://jpn.up.pt/2017/05/29/exposicao-cidade-global-museu-soares-dos-reis/ (accessed 2018-9-1).
[46] `ICOM Code of ethics for natural history museums' (2013), ICOM, https://icomnatistethics.files.wordpress.com/2013/09/nathcode_ethics_en2.pdf (accessed 2019-6-11).
[47] `E.C.C.O. professional guidelines (II). Code of ethics' (2003), E.C.C.O., http://www.ecco-eu.org/fileadmin/user_upload/ECCO_professional_guidelines_II.pdf (accessed 2018-9-1).
[48] `The operational guidelines for the implementation of the World Heritage Convention' (2012), UNESCO, http://whc.unesco.org/en/guidelines/ (accessed 2018-9-1).
[49] `The Nara Document on Authenticity' (1994), ICOMOS, https://www.icomos.org/charters/nara-e.pdf (accessed 2019-06-11).
[50] `The Burra Charter' (1999), Australia ICOMOS, https://australia.icomos.org/publications/charters/ (accessed 2019-06-11).
[51] `Nhcoll-l ± Natural History Collections Listserver’, https://mailman.yale.edu/mailman/listinfo/nhcoll-l (accessed 2018-9-1).
[52] `Swiss museum saws horns off stuffed rhinos to prevent theft' (2011-12-20), in NBC News, http://photoblog.nbcnews.com/_news/2011/12/20/9580465-swiss-museum-saws-horns-off-stuffed-rhinos-to-prevent-theft?lite (accessed 2018-9-1).
[53] Wheeler, R., `Norwich Castle rhino gets replica horns in attempt to foil thieves' (2012-10-20), in Eastern Daily Press, https://www.edp24.co.uk/news/norwich-castle-rhino-gets-replica-horns-in-attempt-to-foil-thieves-1-1663231 (accessed 2016-9-1).
[54] Larkin, N.; Moore, S., `Moulding the horns of a rhinoceros to make replicas for display’, in Natural-History-Conservation.com, http://www.natural-history-conservation.com/rhinohorn.htm (accessed 2018-9-1)
[55] Larkin, N.; Moore, S., `Making replicas of rhino horns and attaching them to taxidermy specimens on display at the Powell-Cotton Museum, Quex Park.’, in Natural-History-Conservation.com, http://www.natural-history-conservation.com/quexpark.htm (accessed 2018-9-1).
[56] `Replica Rhino Horns’, in Museum, National Museum of Ireland, https://www.museum.ie/The-Collections/Conservation/Conservation-Projects/Replica-Rhino-Horns (accessed 2016-9-1).
[57] Monaghan, N., personal communication, National Museum of Ireland, Dublin (2016-9-7).
[58] Morris, P. A., Rowland Ward: Taxidermist to the World, MPM Publishing, Ascot, (2003).
[59] Ward, R., The Sportman's Handbook to Pratical Collections, Preserving and Artistic Setting-up of Trophies and Specimens, London (1880).
[60] Pécquignot, A., `The history of taxidermy: clues for preservation’, Collections. A Journal for Museums and Archives Professionals 2 (3) (2006) 245-255, https://doi.org/10.1177/155019060600200306.
[61] Marte, F.; Pécquignot, A.; Von Endt, D. W., `Arsenic in taxidermy collections: history, detection, and management’, Collection Forum 21(1-2) (2006)143-150.
[62] Teixeira, C., `Relatório preliminar de análise de amostras: técnicas DRX e microssonda nuclear’, unpublished report, Curso Técnicas Nucleares para a Valorização do Património Cultural, Departamento de Engenharia e Ciencias Nucleares, Instituto Superior Tecnico, Universidade de Lisboa (2016).
[63] Alves, L., `Análises PIXE ± Amostras do Curso Técnicas Nucleares para a Valorização do Património Cultural’, unpublished report, Departamento de Engenharia e Ciencias Nucleares, Instituto Superior Tecnico, Universidade de Lisboa (2016).
[64] `Elastosil® M mouldmaking compounds ± made easy’, Wacker Chemie, https://www.wacker.com/cms/media/publications/downloads/6007_EN.pdf (accessed 2018-9-1).
[65] `Resina de poliéster pré-acelerada’, Santos e Elvas, https://santoseelvas.pt/produto/resina-poliester-pre-acelerada (accessed 2019-1-1).
[66] `Fiberglass’, in Cameo, Museum of Fine Arts, Boston, http://cameo.mfa.org/wiki/Fiberglass (accessed 2019-1-1).
[67] `Release agents, additives & ancillaries’, BÜFA, https://www.buefa.de/media/komplettprogramm_release_agents.pdf (accessed 2018-9-1).
[68] `Technical data sheet ± AC 100’, Jesmonite, http://jesmonite.com/cms/wp-content/uploads/2017/02/AC100-Technical-Data-Sheet-2017.pdf (accessed 2018-9-1).
[69] `Apoxie® Sculpt’, Aves, https://www.avesstudio.com/shop/apoxie-sculpt/# (accessed 2018-9-1).
[70] `High Density PU, Duromer, Polyol + Isocyanate 9190/HT16’, http://www.gruposynthesia.com/es/ver/categorias/69/pu-alta-densidad (accessed 2018-9-1).
[71] Cardwell, N., `Rhino horn: fooling the thieves lured by riches’, in BBC News, http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/mobile/uk-14696639 (accessed 2018-9-1).
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
This work is distributed under a Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY-NC-ND 4.0) which permits use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium following no commercial or derivatives, provided the original author and source are credited.
Copyright remains with the authors.
